Should Justice Be Returned to His Owner

by Jim McBean on December 21, 2009 · View Comments

The Youtube video that follows shows a dog named Justice in very bad shape. He’s underweight, suffering from extreme mange and has bite marks on his neck.

I learned of Justice on Dog Examiner’s Facebook Page. If you head over there you can read the comments and updates on his story, but apparently he was living in a back yard in NYC with another dog who constantly attacked him. A neighbor (disgusted by Justice’s condition and the conditions in which he was living), took Justice to the ASPCA without his owner’s permission. Now apparently the ASPCA in New York is preparing to return Justice to his owner.

If the limited facts of this story are accurate, there is NO WAY this dog should be returned to his owner, regardless of how he ended up at the ASPCA. The health and welfare of this poor animal need to be priority 1!

Please retweet this post on Twitter, share it on Facebook, email it to friends, whatever you can do to get Justice’s story in front of as many eyeballs as possible. Justice deserves justice!

YouTube Preview Image


UPDATE:12/29/2009

There is still very little, well actually no information becoming available regarding Justice’s safety, whereabouts or health status. I’ve just tweeted the ASPCA NY to see if they have any information that they are able to share.

UPDATE 2: 12/29/2009

I was just alerted by @K9Stitch via Twitter of a new Facebook group called ASPCA We Need Justice For Justice. There looks like there is A LOT going on legally behind the scenes over there. Hopefully all the hard work people are doing culminate in “Justice” being removed very soon from the terrible conditions he’s been living in and given the treatment he needs so badly.

Take a minute to visit this Facebook group, join & spread the word. If you have relevant legal expertise, I’m sure it would be welcome to the people trying to rescue “Justice” from his terrible situation.

UPDATE 3: 12/30/2009

Justice’s story has made the front page of the Care2 website.

UPDATE 4: 12/31/2009

Latest update from the Justice for Justice Facebook group.
Joseph Villarosa December 31 at 8:52am Reply
Please comment on the Justice Page, NOT to me unless it’s VERY important. The below missive is on the page

Joseph Villarosa ** Joseph Alert **
PLEASE read these words carefully…
1. To the world, WE are looking like a bunch of nuts. WE need to calm down, stop pointing fingers at EACH others and THINK HARD before posting. If you are not “contributing” to a meaningful discussion, go play on another page. This is serious stuff and we have …WAY too many radical and opinionated cooks in the kitchen. I WANT your input, but THINK before bashing PLEASE. OK? MY job is to bash, not yours (grin).

2. I have asked for a second video to be taken of BOTH dogs, cross fingers PLEASE.

3. The family attorney DID contact me last night. See prior update. I will reach out to them again.

4. Attorney Merino is doing her best and has contacted EVERY group in the world that could help (ASPCA, owners, etc.).

5. Our friends at Rescue Ink are ALL over this. They will NOT let anything happen to these dogs. So let’s continue to support them please.

6. Justice IS doing better and IS getting treatment. This was ONE of our goals, so we WON PART of the fight people, BUT we STILL have much work to do.

7. I am TRYING to broker a backdoor deal with everyone. No one will ever be told the terms, but suffice it to say, if it works it creates a win-win for the dogs, for LEGAL JUSTICE and will send a… See More STRONG signal to the ASPCA. I’m a deal maker. So sit tight, I’ve doing everything I can (as have you).

8. Please do NOT friend me w/o a note. I have no clue who many of you are and I have to be careful who I let into my paranoid little world (grin).

9. We should NOT have the demonstration tonight. Give it a rest and let’s regroup and calm down. Besides, the real place that needs a protest are our politicians who ALLOW the f’d up laws, the NYPP who don’t even KNOW the animal laws and the ASPCA who is, well, clueless on every level.

10. The owners and Justice are only pawns in a VERY political game with LOTS of money at stake. And don’t fool yourself, this is ALL about donations and $$$ – to the system, this is NOT about Justice. So let’s not take our eyes off the REAL prizes. ** Better laws. ** Better enforcement ** Education of laws TO ASPCA AND NYPD ** National Companion Animal Protection Act (CAPA) like law ** Roundtable conference with ALL parties (NYPD, ASPCA, HSUS, US, politicians etc.) ** Passage of Oreo law ** NATIONAL animal rights think tank that I feel WE should start!!! ** National Rescue and Shelter UNION which I feel WE should start as a 501c3. THESE are the ways to cut off the head of the snake. So PLEASE realize, I get it. Justice is the poster dog representing the FACT that our animal welfare system is broken. We need reform people. NATIONAL reform. NOT talk. NOT politics. NEW LAWS. NOW PLEASE have a safe New Year and PLEASE let’s all just give this all a rest for a bit and save some OTHER lives.

This one is OK for now…I promise.

  1. What Do Those Pretty Little Buttons Do?
  2. Using Twitter To Save Dogs’ Lives
  3. Toronto Humane Society President Charged with Animal Cruelty
  • martha caballero
    does anyone have any update about justice or was this just a for the moment concern and dropped..do any of these babies really see justice,, pls someone give me back up info.. last i tried site was closed.. pl dont tell me this is yet another classic swept unkder the rug situation..ty.
  • RB
    I have tried to get info to about Justice but have been unable to.
  • I was actually looking earlier in the week for more info, but there's nothing. My blog comes up first in most searches. It looks like the Facebook group is gone, the ASPCA's Facebook page hasn't been updated since January, and I can't find any info anywhere else. If you're able to, please post it here.
  • MARTHA CABALLERO
    i have posted on several comments in a orderly fashion ,, with respect and concern.. obviously i have hit a nerve or a point whichever comes first.. i do not apoligize to anyone but to justice who will in the end get the flac over this if he hasnt already.. pls lets stay focus ...myself included on what the real problem is.. that being getting justice and other dogs out of there hands and into a safe and loving inviroment..
    i have looked at all the video.. first of all the second dog is behind a wired fence.. so this cant be the other dog being that they are suppose to be in the same crawl space.. second.. with the cuts.bruses/abuse //skin disorder/burnts/bites lathrogic statee//that justice was in there is no way this is the samed animal.. needless to say his weight and the fact he looks like a puppy here in these movies. whom ever filmed this video might have in all honesty thought this was the same dog.. but lets look at some points
    if u look close enough you do not see the degree of bites/cuts scraps/bruises/skin disorder that he had obtain... mange takes weeks to heal.. dermotogic also takes a few weeks.. just as when a person has a terrible skin infection.. another thing if he is supposbile being treated for these aliments.. he is not suppose to be outside because one they have to apply cream.. ltwo he is a high risk for infection..
    last but not least... in the video before he goes into the crawl space or whatever that is.. you can clearly see his neck.. did you view the photo besides the orginal video .. he had deep seeded wounds ..especialy around the neck.. this would not heal at such a fast rates especially if he is in the same inviroment and outside.
    point is.. lets say all above is so. and God in his mercy made a miracle. because i too believe in the power of God...... See More
    WE ARE STILL LOSING SIGHT OF THE MAIN OBJECTIVE BEING...REMOVING JUSTICE AND FRIENDS... NOT THAT WE TURN AWAY BECAUSE A VIDEO SHOWS MAYBE HE IS IN BETTER SHAPE.
    THE PROBLEM STILL REMAINS.. HE IS STILL WITH HIS ABUSERS......
    FIREST OF ALL THE VET THAT TURNED HIM BACK TO HIS OWNERS IN THE STATE HE WAS IN IN THOSE VIDEO SHOULD BE BROUGHT UP ON CHARGES AND LOSE THERE LISENCE TO EVER PRATICE AGAIN.
    SECOND ASPCA WHO NEVER REMOVED THE DOG AND IF THEY DID RETURNED.. SHOUDL BE BROUGHT UP ON CHARGES FOR NEGLECT AND ABUSE ON THE RIGHTS ON WHAT THIS ASPCA IS SUPPOSE TO STAND FOR
    THIRD THE OWNERS THEMSELVES SHOULD BE BROUGHT UP ON CHARGES OF ABUSE NEGLECT AND ENDANGERMENT TO THE COMMUNITY IF ONE OF THOSE STARVING SICK ANIMALLS WERE TO GET LOSE..IT COULD BE YOUR CHILD TO SATISFIY ITS HUNGER OR EVEN PAIN OUT OF FEAR..
    AGAIN MAIN OBJECTIVE WAS TO HAVE THEM REMOVED.. PLACE IN SAFE INVIROMENT,.. THEM PROCEED WITH THE ABOVE STATED PROBLEMS TO INSURE THIS NEVER EVER HAPPENS AGAIN. I HAVE SAID MY PEACE.. RESPECTFULLY AND WITH CONCERN.. JUSTICE AND FRIENDS YOU ARE IN MY PRAYERS.. I HOPE WE WILL BE ABLE TO DO SOMETHING FOR U AS NO ANIMAL SHOULD SUFFER.. I AM SORRY ON MY PART FOR THE HATE IGNORANCE OF PEOPLE IN THE WORLD. HUGS MARTHA
    2 seconds ago ยท
  • martha caballero
    the dog Justice was returne dto his owners.. supposeble the vet that treated him felt he was not seriously hurt enough to charge these people and have them remove the dog.. instead they gave back to owners
    then aspca has not removed the dog either...
    finally the owners still have the dog.. the focus should be to have the dog removed and place in a rescue shelter .. we have alot of people willing to take justice and give a loving home.. what is the problem.. why is he still with his abusers.. these people have money this is unacceptable even if u pwhere poor.. cant take care of an animal ..dont have it.. simple
  • Robin
    I have been Speaking out for Animals for some time now and this is the first time I have actually taken flack from another Animal rescuer ( at another site). I am unyielding in spite of it..THANK GOD.
    Please tell me what to do from Oregon to help Justice. I have made numerous phone calls, sent emails, post's, etc. I feel helpless to be able to get Justice out. I wish I could hop on a plane and just march in there and get him and the other dog there. All of my tears over this is helping no one but still they come because of the suffering of the dog's.
    I am waiting to hear what I can do...please email me if you would like me to make more calls. I hope the New Year will begin with Justices freedom from cruelty.
  • OnnTheDL
    UPDATE:

    People are headed over to the residence as we speak to protest and hopefully get video of Justice out back. You can check out the Facebook Page Justice for Justice listed above with the link, and I will update later. Hopefully with enough pressure the morons will willingly realease both Justice and Champ. Praying and Paws crossed!
  • OnnTheDL
    How do we know who the moderators are here? Thanks ;-)
  • My info is on the Aboutpage.
  • OnnTheDL
    TY ;-)~
  • I am not sure how FOIL requests relate to NON-governmental entities but you might want to try that route. A FOIL request is a Freedom of Information request and is usually made to a legal department or perhaps even a corporate communications department. Might be worth a shot to get info about this dog.
  • OnnTheDL
    FOIL would not apply in this situation. But thank you for thinking OUT OF THE BOX!!!! Now let's get others to DO THE SAME!!!! ;-)
  • u bet the dog is not w/the ASPCA! they have Done nothing to help him n the other dog!even after people have reported it to them this dog has mange n is being kept outside in a crawl space under the house by a restaurant owner[ Greek] not a poor guy,in below zero temps. people everywhere are trying to help but not THE NEW YORK ASPCA!!! they are totally ignoring the problem hoping it goes away IT WON`T .
  • OnnTheDL
    Do you have the name of the restaurant? Address or numer? The name would be AWESOME I can get the rest if you don't have them. Post it here, or email it to: Act4Justice@aol.com THANKS!!!!!
  • Please do not post name or address information here. Most of that information is on the Justice for Justice Facebook page.
  • OnnTheDL
    Why can we not post names or addresses here? Not everyone has seen the FB page. Wouldn't it make sense to have the information plastered on every site we can as long as we make it clear that we are to act in a peaceful reasonable manner? I am only asking that those people who say they want to help actually do something other than post they want to help... ;-) I do understand that we do not want to promote physical confrontation, but just sitting here on a computer hoping others will do something is NOT working. KNIM? Thanks for your help!!! ;-)~
  • I'm not a lawyer, but I can see legal implications arising from posting somebody's personal information for the world to see.

    Imagine that the name and address information is incorrect, or maybe it is correct. Then imagine a would be rescuer going to that location and being confronted with a weapon, or vice versa. This is just one scenario out of countless possible ones that could go wrong for all parties involved, including Justice.

    The people that started the Facebook group that I mention above are going through the proper legal channels - they are doing something, they're not just sitting behind their computers.

    Justice's situation has gone viral thanks to the Youtube video, the Dog Examiner Facebook page, the Justice for Justice Facebook group, the Care2 website, and hopefully this blog, as well as all the people that have commented & tweeted about Justice's story from various websites.
  • OnnTheDL
    I can assure you they are correct and verified via public records and by peronally calling. That is why I only have 2 thus far after almost 2 weeks of searching. I do undertand your position however. The information has been gathered legally and under P.I. standards. I have posted the information on the Justice for Justice facebook page, Dog Examiner FB, and the You Tube Video. For the record, I do work-)for one of the gropus indicated. ;-)

    V/R

    OnntheDL
  • OnnTheDL
    Please if you have any information on the owners of Justice themselves, their relatives, their places of business, anything, please email it to:
    Act4Justice@aol.com
    ALL information will be kept strictly confidential. THANK YOU!!!!
    Any VALID information you can supply us with will be tremedously helpful in assisting those trying to save Justice.
  • ALF
    JUSTICE -UPDATE-
    Time to put this into the hands of people that will get the job done right the first time!!!!

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f1_V6MgciXI
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post:

Get Smart with the Thesis Theme from DIY Themes!

Doggy Bytes on Twitter Doggy Bytes on Facebook My Dog Rocks Bookmark this Doggy Bytes RSS Feed Jim's Email